Studying the impact of innovation on business and society

Why Authenticity Matters

Guest post by Jeremy Toeman: Follow him on Twitter | Read his blog


There’s a blog post on MobileCrunch regarding a PR firm having their employees/interns put up fake product reviews on behalf of their clients. For the younger folk in the industry, let me make sure it’s clear that these techniques are nothing new. The difference is in today’s world the risks associated with such a move are so much higher, as you are more likely to get caught. For us to simply say “duh, don’t do it” just isn’t enough. The massive shift into self-publishing platforms (aka “the era of social media” – yawn) has radically enabled individuals to expose virtually every “truth” that’s out there.

This means disingenuous behavior is more likely to be exposed to the public than ever before. While I hear “gurus” preaching about openness and transparency, our advice to clients leans more toward the importance of authenticity. Sure there is value in some amount of transparency, but it is hard to properly define and must have limits (companies *are* allowed to work on secret projects, and we must preserve this ability). Whereas preaching authenticity simply has no bounds and is easily definable.

In a nutshell, a company must behave, in every way and at every time, authentic. Nothing fake, anytime. But that doesn’t mean you cannot sing your own praises, nor hire others to do so on your behalf. You must, however, make sure it is known.

Some examples:

Personal Blogging: If you have a personal blog, you must have an “about” page which clearly lists your employment. Further, on any blog post that particularly pertains to a topic related to your company/industry, you must add a disclaimer/disclosure statement to that post. There is no such thing as too much clarity when it comes to potential conflicts of interest.

Commenting: Same as per blogging, with some extra rules. First, no anonymous comments, anytime, anywhere, ever, on anything industry-related (I additionally recommend no anonymous comments on non-work-related blog posts too, but that’s more a matter of principles). Second, don’t be intentionally deceptive in comments, especially if it pertains to your competition. Third, don’t comment when you aren’t adding value to the discussion – if you can’t find a way to get “your message” in naturally, it’s probably best saved for a future time (this can be painful at times, but is a great rule to follow).

Ratings: The best policy possible would be to abstain for rating your own (or competitor’s) products. But even the President is allowed to vote for himself in an election, so ultimately I see no reason why you cannot give your own product a 5-star rating on a review site. That is, if you have used the product! There should be no “rallying the troops” to game a system. If you haven’t used your own company’s product, you have no business rating it. It should go without saying by this time that no “fake” ratings are ever acceptable.

Popularity Contests/Votes: This is one of the trickiest topics in my opinion. The problem is these systems are inherently gamed – in other words, nobody should ever assume they are honest. As an example, for last year’s NHL All-Star game, one of the fans of the Canadians created a script to auto-vote for the players. It wasn’t done or condoned by the team. But we all know using it was wrong, even if we wanted our team to win. As a result, they did win numerous spots on the ballots, but it’s shrouded in distrust (despite the fact that Montreal also boasts of one of the largest fan bases of any NHL team AND had a solid lineup that year AND the NHL claims they were able to purge the auto-votes from the system). My general philosophy is that all popularity contests are bad things, and everyone should avoid them like the plague. If you must participate, well then one-person, one-vote, and just leave it at that.

Incidentally, when we train companies on the above behaviors, we recommend they be passed around not just internally to the entire team, but to friends of the company as well. Spouses, other family members, investors, roommates, etc should all be playing from the same book.

And now for a positive-minded case study. When I worked at Sling Media, we were doing “social media marketing” long before it even had such a label (and before all the so-called experts even knew what an online community was). We were big believers in letting our product speak for itself. We all followed the above guidelines, and as a result, I can still look back at the product’s Amazon page 4 years later and see a 4.5 star average review from almost 200 people.

I can show that link with pride, not only in that we built an amazing product, but that it’s reviews were authentic and genuine. Yup, I sleep at night pretty well.

It is not uncommon for a company to find themselves in a position where being opportunistic would appear to have good results. I do believe that good products ultimately speak for themselves (as do bad ones), and if you want to practice any kind of sustainable marketing, you need to let the natural course of events transpire. Can you engage your user community to go write product reviews? Sure – they are your customers! Can you offer them a free company product to do so? No – that’s called a bribe, and it’s never acceptable.

Whether it’s blogging, tweeting, social networks, or other vehicles for communication, it’s safe to say that cover-ups are near-impossible to pull off. Every action you take that is disingenuous or unauthentic will be remembered. Fake reviews will be sniffed out. We recommend taking the high road, regardless of what you see others doing. It may take all your strength at times to not take the easy path, but trust me, it’s worth it in the end.

Please also read, “PR Continues to Contribute to Its Branding Crisis and Inevitable Renaissance

151 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Why Authenticity Matters”

  1. Guest says:


    We can preach this to clients, but unless these companies get called out, this practice will still continue.

    Sometimes I feel like 2.0 needs a whistle-blower to shake things up.

  2. Paul L'Acosta says:

    Very well put, sooner or later you’ll get caught (because we humans are social by nature and we always need to tell someone).

  3. Anita Neville says:

    Timely post for me. I work in Sustainability Communications and Green Marketing. Just last week an ad agency sent me a concept that involved a “fake” story from the field. Somehow someone thought that in promoting the ethical credentials of their client it was OK to make up a story from the point of view of a child living on a sustainably managed farm. It wasn’t, it isn’t. There’s a great deal of cross over between green marketing and social media marketing in terms of the need for authenticity, transparency and dare I say, humility. Thanks again

  4. Alex Hawkinson says:

    Completely agree with this.  I think that the importance of authenticity is only amplified in the case of small businesses who literally live or die based on the trust and word of mouth marketing and referalls from a handful of customers.  Posted more thoughts and a good example of a small business following these practices here –

    Thanks for another thought provoking post, Brian.

  5. Pingback: Timi will share…
  6. Timi Stoop-Alcala says:

    Thanks for highlighting the need for authenticity. Being fake these days is ineed taking a greater risk. What one of the advertising fathers, William Bernbach, said of advertising then still rings true — and even louder –  today: “A great ad campaign will make a bad product fail faster. It will get more people to know it’s bad.” Translated in today’s language: don’t be the evil and deceitful company, because #EpicFail will bring you to justice.

    While the greater likelihood of getting caught and exposed to the public is reason enough to not engage in ‘general fakery’ these days, I think it should not be the compelling reason. Think culture, not tactics. Design ethics, not deceit. The choices we make as designers, information architects, developers, advertisers, PR firms, and brands all contribute to the development of the ethics of user experience. 

  7. Web Designer in Va says:

    The web offers a myriad of opportunities … both good and bad!

  8. greenmecca says:

    Advertising media is this accurate in pinpointing a company’s target market.We can deliver a target that is as narrow or broad as anyone can imagine. 

  9. codruta says:

    Totaly agree. Letting people sincerly review your product can bring a great advantage: it will help you improve it, see it’s weak points.

    great post, thanks

  10. Steve Fitzgerald says:

    Very much enjoyed this post, and am in complete agreement. Another example (which may simply dovetail into one of your principles above) would be the editing or removal of negative reviews and comments from products – or anywhere. This obviously applies when the brand in question owns the specific medium/site and can moderate it…

  11. LauraT says:

    @briansolis Why authenticity Matters

  12. Jeremy Toeman says:

    Thanks for all the great feedback and RT’s everyone!!! I put up a “sequel” post here:

  13. Gagan Biyani says:

    Hey Jeremy,

    Just want to say: loved your post and I hope all PR professionals follow similar guidelines. Awesome.

    Gagan Biyani


  14. source says:

    Hello im an original verified seller around since CARDER PLANET, SHADOW CREW MAZAFAKA etc
    My name is SOURCE
    I also go by Exskalibur in some forums
    Im back after long vacation, and have something special this time 🙂
    Dumps+Pins database obtained via ingenico 3070 pinpads in north america in luxury resorts and spas
    I have debit visa/mc tracks+pins from usa, and canada debit/CREDIT atm tracks+pins
    These will work only in north america,
    some will work in UK and the carribean BUT NOT ALL!
    They will NOT work in europe or asia
    Im selling this for 250$ each and guarantee minimum 1000$+++ per or I will replace immediately.
    This is for withdrawal from atms with cirrus/maestro/plus/visa/mastercard/amex networks
    if your atm has a sticker with one of these logos in north america it will work on that ATM
    NO FREE TEST, no chit chat, no time wasting
    I DONT NEED CASHIERS, im just selling these, if you want to buy contact me, otherwise leave me alone
    I dont have anything else for sale at the moment like cvv, paypals, fullz,or cc dumps without pin
    contact me by email only

  15. frank barry says:

    Thanks Jeremy. It’s an important topic to cover because everyone is tempted to gain the edge and get easy wins. It’s human nature (I think?).

    Being authentic or having a good character with things like voting systems is important. It’s also important with social media at large. The world of social media is all about good people doing good things. Not self promotion. If you are one of “those guy’s” or an organization that is always self serving the community will sniff you out at some point.

  16. Pingback: Anonymous

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join Our Mailing List

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Stay Connected